After the Civil War, Jefferson Davis spent two years in
prison without trial. He was released on bail and a year and a half later, the
government finally dropped the treason charges against him. In 1877 he retired
to Beauvoir, where he wrote, The Rise and Fall of the Confederate Government.
This was a two-volume tome of over 1,500 pages. I did not read this book. I
tried, but I kept following asleep. Luckily, ten years later, Davis wrote A Short History of the Confederate States of America. Roughly one-third in
length, “A Short History” covers the same ground and is more readable.
Davis writing style is clear for modern readers, but I would
recommend a good understanding of the war to provide context for his narrative.
That said, for a thorough understanding of a major historical event, it always best
to get the story from the horse’s mouth. The Davis perspective may be biased,
but those perspectives did not change between the war and the writing of his
memoir. That consistency makes this book valuable for understanding the motivations
for war.
Davis extols victories and offers strained excuses for
errors and failures. In Davis’ mind, nothing was his fault, the Confederacy was
always honorable, the Union always vile. For those not imbued with The Cause
mythology, this heavy-handed prejudice can be off-putting, but I found it
helps understand the ethos of the period.
Most history books are written by winners. If you don’t
study the losers, then you have an incomplete picture. An example would be the hallowed
Federalist Papers. There is a collection of opposition opinion pieces
called the Anti-Federalist Papers. I suggest reading both and I highly
recommend Jefferson Davis’ A Short History of the Confederate States of America.
(This is a research book for Maelstrom, a sequel to Tempest at Dawn.)
No comments:
Post a Comment